| Article # |
Citation |
Fidelity to Stanford CDSMP |
Randomization Notes |
Site Information |
Screening |
Country / Region |
| 1 |
Ahmed & Villagra (2006) |
no stated modifications |
non-random |
10 sites |
none specified, selection favored those with diabetes |
Chicago, Kansas, Dallas, Houston, Denver, Mid-Atlantic, Nashville, Florida, Ohio, Tri-state |
| 3 |
Barlow, Turner, et al (2009) |
CDSMP implemented by NHS, with lay leaders |
MS patients randomized to treatment of control; also followed group of informed nonattenders |
12 courses; # sites & geographical spread not specified |
Multiple Sclerosis patients |
England |
| 4 |
Barlow, Wright, et al (2005) |
CDSMP implemented by NHS, with lay leaders |
non-random |
|
none specified |
England |
| 7 |
Bedell (2008) |
Modified version of CDSMP for work transition & self-management skills for HIV/AIDS patients. |
non-random |
The study took place at MTS, a job skills training program for persons with HIV/AIDS |
This study is for persons with HIV/AIDS who are in work transition. |
New York City |
| 12 |
Ersek, Turner et al (2008) |
Modified CDSMP program for PAIN |
Recruitment from 43 retirement communities. 36 facilities were randomized & 7 facilities randomized individually |
43 retirement communities |
Exclusion criteria were active cancer or surgery next 6 months |
Puget Sound area of Washington State |
| 14 |
Gitlin, Chernett, et al (2008) |
Modified for urban older African Americans in Philadelphia, delivered by a senior center. named Harvest Health. |
non-random |
38 course conducted over 3 years |
older African Americans |
Philadelphia, PA |
| 15 |
Goeppinger , Armstrong et al (2007) |
CDSMP & Arthritis Self-help Course (ASHC). Only one or the other was administered to a participant. They were modified for cultural acceptability. |
Randomization at group level to receive CDSMP or another Arthritis specific program. Not randomized within program |
48 workshops; # sites not specified |
none specified; predominantly African American |
Southeastern U.S.; 12 counties in eastern North Carolina |
| 17 |
Haas, Groupp, et al (2005) |
no stated modifications |
Participants randomized to receive workshop immediately (treatment) or wait for 6 months (control group) |
12 sites (OASIS institute, 2 YMCAS, 5 senior residences, 1 community center, 1 church |
African American or White, aged 60+, suffer from chronic LBP, ability to read & write English. Exclusion: dementia, significant heart or respiratory illness, serious blood disorders, participation in another health program, unwillingness to be randomized. |
not specified. In U.S. |
| 19 |
Jerant, Moore-Hill et al (2009) |
Used Homing in on Health (HioH), a CDSMP variant |
Randomized into control, and treatment at home or telephone |
Those receiving treatment by home and telephone compared to control; recruitment through 12 physician offices |
Ability to speak & read English; residence in home with telephone; adequate hearing and eyesight; at least 1 activity impairments |
northern California |
| 21 |
Kendall, Catalano, et al (2007) |
Modified CDSMP for recent stroke patients |
Stroke patients randomized to treatment and control |
single hospital |
stroke patients |
southeast Australia |
| 22 |
Kennedy, Reeves, et al (2007) |
CDSMP implemented by NHS, with lay leaders |
Randomized on participant level |
National: Recruitment by 28 strategic health authorities |
none specified |
England |
| 24 |
Lorig, Ritter et al (2001) |
no stated modifications |
non-random |
not-specified |
none specified |
US |
| 25 |
Lorig, Ritter, et al (2008) |
Online version of EPP (Expert Patients Programme), based on the CDSMP |
non-random |
online |
exclusion: treatment for cancer, being pregnant |
England |
| 26 |
Lorig, Ritter, Gonzalez, et al (2003) |
Spanish-language version called Tomando Control de Su Salud: not direct translation, cultural modifications |
Participants randomized to treatment and wait listed control |
58 programs |
targeted Hispanic population |
northern California |
| 27 |
Lorig, Ritter, Jacquez, et al (2005) |
Spanish-language version called Tomando Control de Su Salud: not direct translation, cultural modifications |
non-random |
31 Spanish programs/ 13 English programs |
1+ chronic condition & 18+ |
Texas, New Mexico, & Chihuahua, Mexico |
| 28 |
Lorig, Ritter, Laurent, et al (2006) |
Online version of CDSMP |
Participants randomized to intervention group (online + usual care) or control group (usual care only) |
online |
exclusion: treatment for cancer, previous participation in CDSMP |
Not specified. But somewhere in US. |
| 29 |
Lorig, Ritter, Plant, et al (2005) |
Compared Arthritis Self-Management Program (ASMP) & generic CDSMP. |
Two-thirds randomized for disease specific Arthritis SMP |
not mentioned |
exclusion: previous participation in ASMP or CDSMP |
San Francisco Bay Area |
| 30 |
Lorig, Sobel, Stewart, et al (1999) |
no stated modifications |
Participants randomized serially. After all subjects had applied to a specific site, the randomization ratio (treatment versus controls) was determined to assure 10-15 treatment subjects. |
multiple community sites in 4 county area |
exclusion: patients with compromised mentation; cancer patients |
San Francisco Bay Area |
| 31 |
Lorig, Sobel, Ritter, et al (2001) |
no stated modifications |
non-random |
21 sites (8 in Northern California, 6 in Southern California, 1 in Ohio, 1 in Georgia, 3 in Colorado, & 1 in Seattle |
none specified |
Seven KP Regions |
| 32 |
Nolte, Elsworth, et al (2007) |
Fidelity to CDSMP not specifically mentioned. |
non-random |
National: multiple programs, offered by lay leaders & health professionals, |
none specified |
Australia |
| 34 |
Powers, Olsen, et al (2009) |
Modified CDSMP program delivered by nurses via phone |
Randomization at provider & patient level. Primary care providers randomized to receive computer decision support or usual care. Hypertension patients hypertension randomized to nurse telephone support or usual care. |
3 sites: conducted at Durham VA Medical Center |
none specified |
Durham, NC |
| 38 |
Rose, Arenson, et al (2008) |
Adapted to low-income urban African-Americans |
non-random |
A variety of community sites, including senior citizen centers, senior housing for people with lower incomes, and churches |
Low-income urban African Americans |
Philadelphia, PA |
| 41 |
Smeulders, van Haastregt, et al (2009) |
no stated modifications |
Patient level randomization to intervention or control |
Recruitment from 6 hospitals & 21 CDSMP classes |
Congestive Heart Failure patients, able to write, and speak Dutch |
Netherlands |
| 42 |
Sobel, Lorig, & Hobbs (2002) |
no stated modifications |
RCT follow-up |
not specified |
Kaiser Permanent (KP) patients |
Nine KP Regions |
| 43 |
Swerissen, Belfrage, et al (2006) |
CDSMP modified by participants first language (Vietnamese, Chinese, Italian or Greek) |
Participants randomized to intervention and waitlisted control groups |
multiple sites in single state of Australia |
People from Vietnamese, Chinese, Italian and Greek backgrounds suffering from chronic conditions. From low income areas. |
Australia |
5600 Fishers Lane Rockville, MD 20857